Careless driving defence in Ontario
A careless driving charge often follows a collision, laid on the officer's view of who was at fault. It is one of the heaviest tickets in the Highway Traffic Act, and it can be challenged.
- Demerit points: 6
- Fine: $400 to $2,000
- Possible suspension: Up to 2 years
What the charge means
Section 130 of the Highway Traffic Act makes it an offence to drive without due care and attention, or without reasonable consideration for other people using the road. Police commonly lay the charge after rear-end collisions, unsafe lane changes, a loss of control in poor weather, or where they believe the driver was distracted.
A collision on its own does not prove careless driving. The prosecution has to show that your driving fell below what a reasonably careful driver would have done in the same circumstances. A charge is an allegation, and the evidence behind it deserves a close look.
What is at stake
| Demerit points | 6 on conviction |
|---|---|
| Fine | $400 to $2,000 |
| Jail | Up to six months is available to the court |
| Licence | A suspension of up to two years |
| Bodily harm or death | Careless driving causing bodily harm or death is a separate, more serious offence, with fines of $2,000 to $50,000, up to two years in jail and a suspension of up to five years |
| Insurance | Most insurers treat a careless driving conviction as a major conviction |
How we defend it
- We get full disclosure: the officer's notes, witness statements, the collision report, photographs and any video.
- We test whether the evidence proves driving below the required standard, and not simply that a collision happened.
- We look at road and weather conditions, sightlines and what each witness could actually see.
- Where it serves you, we negotiate with the prosecutor for a lesser charge with fewer or no demerit points.
- If the case should be tried, we represent you at trial.
Every case is different, and no result can be promised in advance. What we can promise is an honest assessment at the start and one flat fee for the whole case.
Common questions
Is careless driving a criminal charge?
No. It is a provincial offence under the Highway Traffic Act and does not create a criminal record. Dangerous driving is the criminal charge. Our article on dangerous driving versus careless driving explains the difference.
Can a careless driving charge be reduced?
Every case is different. Some are resolved to a lesser offence after discussions with the prosecutor, and others go to trial. No result can be promised in advance, but we will tell you what is realistic once we have seen the evidence.
My insurer says I was at fault. Does that mean I am guilty?
No. Fault for insurance purposes and guilt in court are decided separately, under different rules. An at-fault finding by your insurer does not prove the charge.
Other tickets we fight
Distracted Driving
Just holding your phone can lead to a charge, even stopped at a red light.
At stake: 3 points, 3-day suspensionStunt Driving & Racing
A 30-day roadside suspension and 14-day impound, before you've even been to court.
At stake: 30-day roadside suspensionRed Lights & Stop Signs
One of Ontario's most common tickets, carrying 3 demerit points on conviction.
At stake: 3 demerit pointsDon't pay that ticket yet.
Send us a photo of your ticket for a free, no-obligation review and a flat-fee quote.